Fanzines Reviewing Fanzines - RTP! #29

Issue #29 of RTP! is reviewed in the most recent issue of Panic Moon. Click here to purchase a copy today!

Sixteen Candles

Issue 16 helped to mark the 40th anniversary of the series Doctor Who by presenting a celebratory comic in Japanese - a decision made by writer/editor Alexander Ballingall for the sheer hell of it. As a concession to those not able to read Japanese script, a translation was provided.

Editorial:

Fandom in the year of the big Four-O

Most of you will be up with the play by now. Doctor Who is on the way back to our screens in a new series. What does this mean for fandom? Can fandom survive the series becoming a popular, talked about public item once more?

I am reminded of the fandom of The X Files where, once the series became of hot item at the conclusion of the second season (1995), there was suddenly a lot of grumbling from those fans who had been loyal viewers from the start about these newbies who were lowering the whole tone of being an X Files fan.

The reason I point this out is because, even without a new series to talk about yet, the older hands on the Outpost Gallifrey message boards are already attacking (a pre-emptive strike if you will) the idiot 'flash-in-the-pan' fans who are lowering the tone of being a Doctor Who fan with their posts on BBCi.

Will new fans with a genuine interest in the show be put off by such an aggressive attitude from the already established fanbase, who have built for themselves a cosy 'us and them' attitude with reference to the series and the public at large.

Love them or hate them the series will always have its professional fans and its uberfans, but in the last fourteen years the general fanbase has shrunk (the Christchurch chapter itself has gone from meetings involving forty-to-sixty people every two months in 1989/90 to eight-to-ten people every three months this year).

It can be argued that fandom desperately needs an injection of new fans into its aging demographic, ones who will carry the torch, so-to-speak, for the series once we, the older fans, are all too senile to appreciate it any more. And while a new series will create such loyal fans who will eventually take our places, there is another group of new fans coming.

On top of all this, can the old guard handle people who will only be fans (ephemeral fans) as long as the series remains popular and who will move on once it drops out of public view again? To again use The X Files example, many fans (cult fans) of the first two seasons moved on to new ground once the show became a popular hit with the general public, unable to remain a fan now that the show was no longer 'something special' for a small, select group of TV watchers. Both of these groups, the cult fans and the ephemeral fans, will help to initially swell the fanbase of Doctor Who, but once the series becomes a hit (and lets face it, it may not) the cult fans will move on and once some other show becomes a hit the ephemeral fans too will move on to pastures greener.

Can fandom, once the increase and then decrease in fans following a new series occurs, and again made up of only loyal fans (that includes those created via the new series), remain a single entity?

Already fandom has split along the lines of those who follow the EDAs/Big Finish audios, and those who don't. Can fandom handle another split like that of Star Trek where fandom has split into 'New Trek' (those who dislike the original series for being too quaint and for having dated SFX) and 'Old Trek' (those who still like the original series)? Would Doctor Who fandom split into newcomers who only watch the new stuff (the older stuff we like being too 'crap') and us, the older fans who retain an appreciation for the older material? Which would DWM place an emphasis on? Which group would the BBC focus more attention on in terms of marketing the series?

But for now at least, us fans can kick back an enjoy both the anniversary that is upon us but also the knowledge that some people somewhere are trying to make a reality the prospect of a new series on our TV sets in 2005.
- Alexander Ballingall

Star Wars - Episode VII: Guff

Published: November 2003
A Doctor Who Fanzine launched by Matt Kamstra & Wade Campbell in October 1997
Editor: Alexander Ballingall
RTP! Logo Design: Peter & Bridget Adamson
Front Cover: Garry Jackson
Back Cover: David Ronayne
Internal Artwork: Peter Adamson, Alexander Ballingall, Gary Jackson, David Ronayne
Letters: Peter Adamson, Jamas Enright, James Gould, Matt Kamstra, Thad Richards [AKA Jamas Enright], Sal Yardley [AKA David Ronayne]
Page Count: 52
Print Run: 25

Price: NZ$3.50

~Contents~

• [01] COVER
• [02] CONTENTS
• [03] The FIRST LAW of TIME
• [04] The TARDIS Manual [Contact/Submission Information]
• [05] The BOOTCUPBOARD [Letters]
• [09] ARTICLE: Fanboy Confidential - Throwing Everything into the Mix
• [16] Comic Translation
• [19] COMIC: "Tomodachi"
• [35] FICTION: "The Masters of Luxor" [part 2 of 6]
• [48] ARTICLE: The Doctor's Cat
• [49] Herr Josheff Z's - Ze Shell-out Tour
• [50] REVIEW: Seeing the Unknown
• [52] COVER

Flashback - The Last of the Golden Summer (RTP! #10)

My primary memory of working on issue #10 is sitting out on the large concrete deck of the flat Matt shared with three of his friends. Ensconced in a crummy deck chair I experimented with laying out the first page of the Aquaman comic and ended up in a chat with Shinobu, the Japanese girlfriend of one of Matt's flatmates. I'm happy to blame the poorly drawn attempt at a manga-style character (on the first page of the comic) on her, but that wouldn't be fair. I'd already started drawing it that way before she turned up and offered her polite comments on my lack of drawing ability.

This would have been late February 2000, as Matt started his third year at University, and I already knew I was headed to the UK in May. I had been at the flat that weekend trying to get the issue done and dusted for publication, something achieved as the issue was published the following month.

The Day the Earth Stood Still

It finally happened. As of now issue #29 is in the postal system!

Not Quite Issue #29...

No, not issue #29 yet! Although this is the other project that has been on the go for about a decade. The finish line is nearly in sight!

15

Issue 15 was RTP! on something of a roll. Issue 14 was only just history and issue 16 would arrive only a couple of months later. 2003 was a year when I had a lot of free time between coming back from Japan and before starting my teacher training. Bob the Suicidal Dalek arrived and is probably the best of the three comic series I've inflicted on readers over the years. Former Doctor Who fanzine editor Jonathan Park got his say in the interview and Pulp Who came to a final end, the entire movie having been adapted in the process.

Editorial:

Milestones

"2003.
As the series celebrates another anniversary in November it seems like a good time to look back at the other milestones that the series has reached in its time:
1963.
BBC management try to can the series before it has even screened.
1969.
The series is kicked of UK television screens and is replaced with the American export Star Trek.
1970.
The BBC have another go at axing the series.
1972.
The BBC decide to start purging their archive of Doctor Who material (see also 1973, 1974, 1975, 1976 & 1977).
1981.
The BBC decide to play around with the scheduling of the series to see how much damage they can do. Sticking it in a time slot where people can actually find it just won't do.
1983.
Producer John Nathan-Turner asks to move onto a different programme and his request is denied (see also 1984, 1985, 1986, 1987, 1988 & 1989).
1985.
BBC 1 Controller Michael Grade decides to axe the series because he doesn't like science fiction (see also The Tripods).
1986.
In a huge vote of confidence by the BBC, the series is scheduled against Coronation Street and reduced to fourteen half-hour episodes a season.
1989.
The series is axed with a promise that it will be back in 1991 ... or maybe 1992. How about 1993? No? 1994 ...?
1996.
The BBC try and fob the series off on an unsuspecting US TV network. When this doesn't work they claim that the TV Movie was a failure, despite high audience figures, and don't make any more of the series.
2001.
An non-anniversary year, of all things, and the BBC refuse to doing anything about bringing the series back to screens around the world. The bastards!!"

- Alexander Ballingall

Schrödinger's Guff

Published: August 2003
A Doctor Who Fanzine launched by Matt Kamstra & Wade Campbell in October 1997
Editor: Alexander Ballingall
RTP! Logo Design: Peter & Bridget Adamson
Front Cover: Peter Adamson
Back Cover: Garry Jackson
Internal Artwork: Peter Adamson, Alexander Ballingall, Garry Jackson, David Ronayne
Letters: Peter Adamson, Jamas Enright, Jon Preddle, David Ronayne, Sal Yardley [AKA David Ronayne]
Page Count: 52
Print Run: 25
Price: NZ$3.50

~ Contents ~

• [01] COVER
• [02] CONTENTS
• [03] The FIRST LAW of TIME
• [04] The TARDIS Manual
• [05] The BOOTCUPBOARD [Letters]
• [09] COMIC: Pulp Who - "The Master and Saucer Smith's Wife" [part 3 of 3]
• [17] ARTICLE: Doctor Who and the Cannibals
• [21] /full page advert/
• [22] ARTICLE: Cannibalism in Doctor Who
• [23] FICTION: "The Masters of Luxor" [part 1 of 6]
• [26] Doctor Joseff Zaroff's Ultimate Challenge
• [27] FICTION: "The Blue Shift"
• [28] INTERVIEW: The Right of Reply
• [33] REVIEWS: James' Corner
• [34] CARTOON: Bob the Suicidal Dalek - "Goes Online"
• [36] Doctor Who Drunken Games
• [37] ARTICLE: The Doctor on the Enterprise
• [44] FICTION: "Return to the Horror"
• [47] REVIEWS: A Big Finish
• [49] 30 Second Theory
• [52] COVER

One Year Later...

Sounds like a zombie film, and RTP! looks a tad like a shuffling corpse. But it isn't dead yet!